Showing posts with label A History of Marginal Utility Theory. Show all posts
Showing posts with label A History of Marginal Utility Theory. Show all posts

Saturday, December 7, 2019

Rejecting Classical Cost Theory, Menger Filled the Gap with a New Version of Galiani's and Condillac's Cost Theory

Menger based his theory of imputation entirely on utility and not on costs. He rejected the classical cost theory, but he still had to explain the value of the factors of production, for otherwise an empty spot remained in his system. He filled the gap with a new version of Galiani's and Condillac's cost theory. Not the value of the cost goods determines the value of the finished goods, but the opposite is true; the value of the consumer goods or, in Menger's terminology, the value of the goods of lower order determines the value of the factors of production or goods of higher order. Menger introduced an interesting refinement into Condillac's statement: not the actual marginal utility of the consumer good but the presumed future value determines the value of capital, labor, and land. Menger, in a theory of production and distribution, emphasized the time element much more strongly than Galiani and even Gossen.

Menger understood quite well that the transfer of value creates a new problem, because factors of production are complementary. They work together in the production of consumer goods. Menger, like Gossen, tried to find a key with which the marginal value of consumer goods can be distributed on each factor inside the factor combination; in this Gossen was more skeptical and cautious than Menger. The latter believed indeed that the problem can be solved and that he had already done so. His interpretation contains ideas which Gossen had already mentioned, and some new suggestions which his student Boehm-Bawerk had refined. Menger's and Boehm-Bawerk's theorem will be discussed together. What Menger thought about this problem is not as important as the fact that he started a discussion in the Austrian camp which is still going on.

—Emil Kauder, A History of Marginal Utility Theory, Princeton Legacy Library (Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press, 1965), 79.



Monday, July 1, 2019

The Theory of Subjective Valuation Was Defended Against the New System Based on Labor Costs by Condillac Who Said “Costs Are Not the Cause of Value; Rather, Value Is the Cause of Costs”

With Galiani and Turgot subjective valuation becomes the keystone for a system of thinking. This theory had to be defended against the new classical system which was based on labor costs. The defense of Galiani, his followers, and his friends was taken over by Condillac. According to him, costs are not the cause of value; rather, value is the cause of costs. Condillac's counter-attack against the classical cost theory is the parting shot of an army falling back. Before 1800 Italian and French writers were already drawn into the orbit of British classical thinking. An attempted synthesis of utility value and cost theory was the main object of later Italian writers.

--Emil Kauder, A History of Marginal Utility Theory (Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press, 1965), 27.


Wednesday, June 26, 2019

Pantaleoni and Weinberger Accused Menger of Plagiarizing Gossen et al. But Menger Did Not Approve of Gossen, Rejecting His Purely Hedonistic Approach, the Application of Mathematics to Psychology, etc.

The new ideas of Menger, Jevons, and Walras were not grafted on the work already done by the early marginalists. The three discoverers were stimulated by some minor writers whom the historians of economic thought usually neglect. Some authors are suspicious of this overflow of discoveries and declare positively that at least Menger must have committed plagiarism.

Maffeo Pantaleoni and Otto Weinberger believed that Menger had read at least Gossen and Mangoldt before he published his discoveries and had concealed this knowledge from his readers. In the Hitotsubashi library, new facts have been discovered which make it unlikely that Menger had copied either author. Menger, indeed, had studied Julius (Gyula) Kautz, who is the earliest author who mentions Gossen (1858), and Menger underlined the two Gossen quotations. But it is still very doubtful that Menger had read Gossen before he finished his Principles. Menger had bought his copy of Gossen on May 8, 1886. The pages are marked in many places, and Menger always did this when he studied an author for the first time. Menger did not approve of Gossen, rejecting his purely hedonistic approach, his emphasis on labor, and the application of mathematics in the realm of psychology. It is not very probable, to say the least, that a writer would copy another author whose methods and findings he does not consider acceptable.

--Emil Kauder, A History of Marginal Utility Theory (Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press, 1965), 81-82.