Showing posts with label The Driving Force of the Market: Essays in Austrian Economics. Show all posts
Showing posts with label The Driving Force of the Market: Essays in Austrian Economics. Show all posts

Wednesday, November 21, 2018

The Dynamic Notion of Competition Pervaded the Bulk of Economics up to the 1920s

In his doctoral dissertation, Frank Machovec documented the thesis that the dynamic notion of competition pervaded the bulk of economics in the neoclassical period up until the 1920s. It was only during the twenties and thirties that equilibrium thinking, and thus the static model of perfect competition, assumed its current dominance in mainstream economic thought. It was presumably this prevalence of the dynamic notion of competition which led Mises into believing, as late as 1932, that the various schools of twentieth-century economic thought shared a common basic understanding of the workings of the market economy.

--Israel M. Kirzner, The Driving Force of the Market: Essays in Austrian Economics, Foundations of the Market Economy (London: Routledge, 2003), 235.


Thursday, October 11, 2018

Ludwig Lachmann and the Centrality of Radical Subjectivism

Few will dispute the observation that the unifying thread running through Lachmann’s social science was his radical subjectivism. It was radical subjectivism that Ludwig Lachmann deployed in order to deepen our understanding of economic processes. And if one seeks to characterize the intellectual odyssey which made up Lachmann’s scholarly career, it seems fair to portray it as a consistent series of deepened, pioneering extensions—the radicalization, if you will—of his own subjectivism. And, we shall see, it is certain characteristic features of Lachmann’s subjectivism which raise the problems with which we wish to grapple in this lecture.

Lachmann was entirely unsatisfied by what he called “subjectivism as the expression of human ‘disposition.’”  It is simply not enough to recognize that decisions made by consumers express the structures of their preferences. Such recognition for the role of subjective tastes would be entirely compatible with the statement of Pareto—a statement cited by Lachmann with disagreement so obviously profound as to border on disbelief—to the effect that once the consumer has left us a picture of his indifference map, we no longer need him at all, since, we then already know exactly what he will decide to do. For Lachmann subjectivism represents, most importantly, “a manifestation of spontaneous action.” By this way of putting it, Lachmann meant to draw attention to the power of the active human mind to frustrate any pretensions by Paretian—or other—economists to predict, simply on the basis of given scarcity constraints impinging on given preferences, what action will in fact be taken.

--Israel M. Kirzner, The Driving Force of the Market: Essays in Austrian Economics, Foundations of the Market Economy (London: Routledge, 2003), 55.

The Subjectivism of the Austrian School

Subjectivism has never, of course, meant any challenge to the possibility of “objective truth” in economics. It has never claimed that “everything is merely a matter of subjective interpretation” by the would-be economist. What the subjectivism of the 1870s challenged was the basic—if unstated—classical tenet that ultimately the only determinant of social-economic phenomena is the objective physical environment. All economic science has endeavored to account for real-world phenomena. The classical economist believed that these phenomena are to be seen as having been inexorably determined by the underlying physical realities. The availability of scarce natural resources, in conjunction with population and its demographics, basically determine the course of human history. What emerges over history is inescapable, it cannot be substantially altered by human will. Economic history emerges as automatically determined by the objective conditions governing and surrounding production. It was against this premise that Menger did revolutionary battle in his 1871 Grundsätze—written, we are told, in what he himself described as “a state of morbid excitement.”

--Israel M. Kirzner, The Driving Force of the Market: Essays in Austrian Economics, Foundations of the Market Economy (London: Routledge, 2003), 41-42.