Showing posts with label Austrian Capital Theory: A Modern Survey of the Essentials. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Austrian Capital Theory: A Modern Survey of the Essentials. Show all posts

Saturday, December 7, 2019

“Menger's Law” States That the Value of All Goods Derives Ultimately from the Utility of the Services of Consumer Goods

Carl Menger, the founding theorist of the Austrian School of Economics, suggested that the material world was composed of goods and services and considered the end of all economic activity to be the consumption of valuable services produced by goods of various “orders.” He divided goods into two exclusive kinds: free goods and economic goods. Free goods are those for which, at a zero price, less would be desired than is available. By contrast, economic goods are those for which, at a zero price, more would be desired than is available. Economic goods are scarce, have value, and will command a positive price if freely traded. Economic goods have value because they yield desirable services. These services provide consumers with utility.

Economic goods may, in turn, be divided into two types: those whose services yield utility directly, first order or consumption goods, and those whose services provide utility indirectly, production goods, or higher-order goods. Production goods provide services that are used in the production of other production goods successively in a supply chain leading to the emergence of consumer goods that provide services yielding utility. Thus, the value of all goods derives ultimately from the utility of the services of consumer goods (Israel Kirzner has called this “Menger’s Law”).

The distinction between stocks and flows is fundamental and important and often neglected. People do not desire goods “in themselves”; they desire what flows from having or renting them. It is the services of goods that are the ultimate objective of economic action. As Menger points out, these can be obtained directly from nature or indirectly by production, using produced instruments of production, production goods.

—Peter Lewin and Nicolas Cachanosky, Austrian Capital Theory: A Modern Survey of the Essentials, Cambridge Elements in Austrian Economics (Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press, 2019), 5.


Saturday, October 5, 2019

In The General Theory, Keynes Is Puzzled by the Austrian School's Use of the Term “Capital Consumption”

The matter was relevant to the Keynes–Hayek debate as well. As Horwitz (2011) notes: “In the only real mention of the Austrian view of capital in The General Theory, Keynes (1936) says:”
It seems probable that capital formation and capital consumption, as used by the Austrian school of economists, are not identical either with investment and disinvestment as defined above or with net investment and disinvestment. In particular, capital consumption is said to occur in circumstances where there is quite clearly no net decrease in capital equipment as defined above. I have, however, been unable to discover a reference to any passage where the meaning of these terms is clearly explained. The statement, for example, that capital formation occurs when there is a lengthening of the period of production does not much advance matters.
Horwitz continues:
Keynes’s dismissiveness aside, this passage reveals much about the differences in approaches. Keynes seems puzzled by the Austrian claim that capital can be “consumed” even though there is no net decrease in physical capital. The answer to the puzzle is that capital, for the Austrians, is about value, not about the physical object itself. If we build a machine in anticipation of some specific future demand and then discover our expectations were wrong, the machine will drop in value (which is a form of capital consumption), but it does not crumple into dust. Capital goods are valued in terms of the (discounted) value of the future consumption goods they will produce. If consumer demand changes, the value of the capital good changes (assuming it is insufficiently versatile to produce whatever new product is now in demand) and capital-value is lost, thus capital has been consumed even though the physical stock of capital has not changed. This [is important in any] discussion of the business cycle. (Horwitz, 2011)
—Peter Lewin and Nicolas Cachanosky, Austrian Capital Theory: A Modern Survey of the Essentials, Cambridge Elements in Austrian Economics (Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press, 2019), 31.


Tuesday, June 18, 2019

Menger Transformed Economics from a Discipline Focused on the Study of Objective Wealth to One Based on Exchange or Catallactics

This theory of capital in Menger’s founding work is completely consistent with his seminal contribution to the subjective theory of value that was a paradigm shift in economics, completely transforming the discipline from one focused on the study of wealth, perceived to be objective (plutology), to one based on exchange (catallactics).
Classical economics was, at least originally, a pragmatic discipline. Its aim was to study means to increase the “wealth of nations”. Its orientation is thus to a macroeconomic magnitude. It needed a measure of wealth, and the classical notion of value was primarily designed to serve this need. Production and distribution of wealth was what really mattered. The consumer was an outsider, not an economic agent . . . . Markets, in classical doctrine, contained producers and merchants only. All this changed when subjective utility replaced objective (and measurable) cost of production as the source of value.
Economics now had to find a place for the consumer. It was he, after all,  who now bestowed value on objects. All non-consumer goods were now shown to have at best purely derivative value. . . . each consumer as an individual would now assign value to objects which become economic goods as a result of his action. (Lachmann, 1986: 145)
--Peter Lewin and Nicolas Cachanosky, Austrian Capital Theory: A Modern Survey of the Essentials, Cambridge Elements in Austrian Economics (Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press, 2019), 7-8.