Showing posts with label Dissent on Keynes: A Critical Appraisal of Keynesian Economics. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Dissent on Keynes: A Critical Appraisal of Keynesian Economics. Show all posts

Monday, December 3, 2018

The Underconsumptionist Solution for Economic Depressions Calls for a Reduction in the Amount of Saving and a Stimulation of Consumption by Issuing New Money

Foster and Catchings, inflationists popular in the 1920s, denounced the capitalist system as inherently deficient because consumers do not have the means to buy the goods they produce, "for every dollar which is saved and invested, instead of spent, causes one dollar of deficiency in consumer buying unless that deficiency is made up in some way." As recommended by Foster and Catchings, that "way" was to issue new money-credits to consumers. E. F. M. Durbin summarizes the underconsumptionist attack on savings as follows:
Saving is a peculiarly dangerous and self-defeating process, for it withdraws money from the purchase of finished commodities and makes their production less profitable, while at the same time it seeks to set up still further capital resources with which the production of finished commodities is to be increased. It is this paradoxical process which makes a deficiency of purchasing power inevitable. It increases the supply of and diminishes the demand for the products of the industrial system to the point at which production cannot be continued any longer with profit and at that point crisis and depression begins. Hence depression can always be prevented and relieved either by reducing the amount of saving or by stimulating consumption by the issue of new money.
--Mark Skousen, "Keynes and the Anti-Saving Mentality," in Dissent on Keynes: A Critical Appraisal of Keynesian Economics, ed. Mark Skousen (New York: Praeger Publishers, 1992), 90.


Sunday, October 21, 2018

Early Rational-Expectations Proponents Criticized Orthodox-Keynesian Models Because Keynesian Models Assume Nobody Learns from Experience

The most dramatic mainstream response to the crisis in Keynesian economics was the development of the "Rational Expectations" approach to macroeconomics. In the hands of Robert E. Lucas (1972), Thomas Sargent and Neil Wallace (1975), Robert Barro (1976), and others, the Rational-Expectations story was at once a critique of Orthodox-Keynesian reasoning as well as an alternative to it. The grounds on which early Rational-Expectations proponents criticized Orthodox-Keynesian models were quite sound. In its simplest form, their argument was that Keynesian models, and particularly Keynesian policy conclusions, were based on the illogical proposition that economic agents, in reacting to fiscal and monetary variable changes, will make systematic errors. Rather than learning from the experience of past policy, they will react the same way each time to, say, countercyclical changes in the money supply. It would be impossible to gauge the amount of stimulus or restraint needed in a given situation if agents reacted differently with learning, but Orthodox-Keynesian models, even the most complicated, were based on the assumption of an intertemporally stable behavioral structure of the economy. As Roger Garrison and I have pointed out, this basic truth of the Rational Expectations school was anticipated by Mises as early as 1953.

--Don Bellante, "The Fork in the Keynesian Road: Post-Keynesians and Neo-Keynesians," in Dissent on Keynes: A Critical Appraisal of Keynesian Economics, ed. Mark Skousen (New York: Praeger Publishers, 1992), 122-123.

The Crisis in Keynesian Theory over the Incompatibility of Rising Inflation Coupled with Rising Unemployment Was Resolved by Ignoring It

There were several responses among mainstream economists to the intellectual crisis associated with the demise of Orthodox Keynesianism. One such response was the growing popularity of Post-Keynesian economics. In many respects, this response was a return to the most primitive version of Keynesian economics, wherein output determination is the subject of economic analysis, but money-wage and price-level movements are seen as sociologically determined (in a tussle over the distribution of income). Hence, the crisis in Keynesian theory over the incompatibility of rising inflation coupled (sometimes) with rising unemployment was resolved by ignoring it, in effect, through seeking refuge in what is really a noneconomic theory of inflation.

--Don Bellante, "The Fork in the Keynesian Road: Post-Keynesians and Neo-Keynesians," in Dissent on Keynes: A Critical Appraisal of Keynesian Economics, ed. Mark Skousen (New York: Praeger Publishers, 1992), 122.