Showing posts with label Macdonald at 200: New Reflections and Legacies. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Macdonald at 200: New Reflections and Legacies. Show all posts

Tuesday, March 26, 2019

Macdonald and His Montreal-Based Supporters Subscribed to the Old Commercial Empire of the St. Lawrence; George Brown Wanted to Settle the North-West to Satisfy Toronto's Economic Ambitions

One of Macdonald’s most-quoted statements about Canadian acquisition of the North-West region was made in a letter to Sir Edward Watkin in March 1865. Watkin, as president of the Grand Trunk Railway, wanted to extend the rail line from the Atlantic to the Pacific and hence pushed for some form of British North American confederation. Macdonald was not as initially enthusiastic about the idea of a transcontinental nation. “I would be quite willing, personally,” he observed on the eve of a trip to London to discuss the confederation agreement, “to leave that whole country a wilderness for the next half-century, but I fear if Englishmen do not go there, Yankees will.” These words nicely captured Macdonald’s quandary — how he was essentially bound by political necessity, and not personal enthusiasm, to Canadian acquisition of the North-West. He and his largely Montreal-based supporters subscribed to the old commercial empire of the St. Lawrence, while the drive to settle the British North-West was a Reform plan, spearheaded by George Brown, to satisfy Toronto’s economic ambitions. But if the Great Coalition of 1864 was to bring about constitutional renewal in place of deadlock, then territorial expansion into the western prairies had to be a planned feature of the Confederation deal (section 146 of the BNA Act). Even then, Macdonald was reluctant to assume control of such a large parcel of land. As Richard Gywn has observed in the first volume of his Macdonald biography, the Conservative leader was preoccupied, if not overwhelmed, with the problems of the United Province of Canada, and his interest in territorial expansion “varied from negligible to non-existent.” His response, in Gywn’s words, was “cautious to a degree.”

--Bill Waiser, "Macdonald's Appetite for Canadian Expansion: Main Course or Leftovers?" in Macdonald at 200: New Reflections and Legacies, ed. Patrice Dutil and Roger Hall (Toronto: Dundurn, 2014), 342-343.


Sunday, March 24, 2019

Direct Taxation Was a (Classical) Liberal Project of Governance Producing Small Government and Engaged Tax Payers Who Closely Scrutinized Government Spending

Fiscal restraint was one way of reining in local governments, in keeping with Macdonald's larger scheme for centralizing as much power as he could. Taxpayers did not feel indirect taxation so intimately and so governments that taxed indirectly could extract more and rationalize less. Direct taxation was a liberal project of governance: it tended to produce small government and vigilant, engaged tax payers who closely scrutinized government spending. English Liberal leader William Gladstone embraced direct taxation and so did George Brown in the Globe, which regularly asserted, in the words of a public meeting at Glenmorris, South Dumfries, in 1867, "Protective duties are unjust in principle and mischievous in practice." In British Columbia, John Sebastian Helmecken opposed Confederation and favoured direct taxation. And, as Andrew Smith has observed, opponents of Confederation across British North America recognized that the scheme was likely to lead to inflated federal taxes and it would not only perpetuate, but expand Macdonald's high-spending ways.

--E.A. Heaman, "Macdonald and Fiscal Realpolitik," in Macdonald at 200: New Reflections and Legacies, ed. Patrice Dutil and Roger Hall (Toronto: Dundurn, 2014), 198.